Best Board Games Like Catan
If Catan sparked your interest in trading, resource management, and modular-map strategy, you’re not alone. Many players look for games like Catan, Catan alternatives, or games similar to Catan that keep the familiar feel of gathering resources and expanding on a changing board while offering deeper strategy, different mechanics, or a fresh theme. This guide describes the best board games like Catan, explains what makes them comparable, and gives practical buying and play advice to help you choose the right next game for your collection.
What makes a game like Catan?
Games comparable to Catan typically share some of these core attributes:
Resource collection & conversion: gather materials (wood, stone, ore, etc.) and turn them into buildings, points, or engines.
Player interaction through trading, blocking, or market mechanics: direct negotiation or indirect competition for shared resources.
Modular boards or variable set-ups: a changing map or tile layout that increases replayability.
Strategic expansion & territory control: placing pieces, roads, or settlements to claim areas and scoring opportunities.
Balance of luck and skill: random elements (dice, card draw) combined with long-term planning.
If you search for best games like Catan, Catan alternatives for groups, or resource management board games, the titles below match those queries while expanding the kinds of decisions and depth you can explore beyond the base Catan experience.
1. Concordia - Best strategic upgrade for players who love economic planning
Overview: Concordia is a euro-style economic strategy game where players guide houses across the Roman world, buying cards, producing goods, and expanding trade networks. It’s light on luck and heavy on planning, with card-driven actions that create engine-building opportunities.
Price: ~€22.00 to ~€50.00+ depending on edition and stock.
Why it’s like Catan: Both games reward efficient resource use and strategic expansion, but Concordia replaces dice and trading with deterministic card "action" selection and a market where production matters. If you like Catan’s resource conversion, Concordia offers a purer, planning-focused evolution of that idea.
Gameplay highlights:
Card-driven action economy (each card equals an action)
Income and scoring based on city presence and traded goods
Low randomness: results stem from choices rather than dice
Players / Time / Weight: 2–5 players, 90–120 minutes, medium weight (complex strategy)
Best for: Groups who want a deeper, less luck-driven economic puzzle and players who enjoy long-term strategic planning.
2. Lords of Waterdeep - Best worker-placement alternative with hidden goals
Overview: Lords of Waterdeep is a worker-placement game set in the Dungeons & Dragons city of Waterdeep. Players assign agents to gather resources (adventurers, gold) to complete quests and build influence, while scoring via completed quests and secret objectives.
Price: ~€35.00 to €45.00 for the base game.
Why it’s like Catan: Lords of Waterdeep echoes Catan’s resource-to-building loop and player interaction, but using worker placement rather than dice/resource generation. Both games reward planning expansions and managing resources to achieve points.
Gameplay highlights:
Worker placement with variable action spaces
Quest cards act like destination tickets / goals
Intrigue cards create player interaction and strategic disruption
Players / Time / Weight: 2–5 players, 60–120 minutes, medium weight
Best for: Players who enjoy Catan’s building and goal-driven play but prefer more deterministic action selection and hidden objectives.
3. Splendor - Best streamlined resource engine for fast strategic turns
Overview: Splendor is an engine-building game where players collect gem tokens to purchase development cards that grant permanent discounts and prestige points. It’s famed for elegant, fast gameplay and clean production values.
Price: ~€25.00 to €40.00, though special/older editions can vary outside that range.
Why it’s like Catan: Splendor shares the core loop of collecting resources to buy cards/buildings that generate more resources or points: similar in spirit to developing settlements in Catan, but far more compact and less negotiation-focused.
Gameplay highlights:
Token collection and card-buying engine building
Quick turns and low setup time
Strong tactile components and clear feedback loops
Players / Time / Weight: 2–4 players, 30–45 minutes, light-medium weight
Best for: New players or groups wanting a shorter, strategic filling-the-role experience that scratches the resource-management itch without extensive table time.
4. Stone Age - Best dice-driven family resource game
Overview: Stone Age is a family-friendly worker-placement and dice-rolling resource management game. Players send tribesmen to gather resources, build huts, advance technology, and score points across a shifting tableau.
Price: Standard retail is typically ~€40.00 to €65.00, depending on edition/retailer.
Why it’s like Catan: Stone Age shares Catan’s core elements (resource gathering, building, and development) while leaning into dice-driven uncertainty and worker allocation rather than hex-based modular maps. It preserves the feel of converting raw materials into structures and scoring benefits.
Gameplay highlights:
Dice determine the yield of resource-collecting actions
Worker placement decisions around scarcity and timing
Simple ruleset with meaningful strategic choices
Players / Time / Weight: 2–4 players, 60–90 minutes, light-medium weight
Best for: Families and groups who enjoy Catan’s accessible resource loop but want a more family-oriented theme with dice excitement.
5. Everdell - Best thematic alternative with tableau-building and charming production
Overview: Everdell blends resource management with tableau building and board development within an immersive woodland theme. Players gather resources to build critter and construction cards, forming a city that scores based on card synergies.
Price: Base game editions are generally ~€35.00 to €90.00+ depending on version/edition; collector/complete bundles can be much higher.
Why it’s like Catan: Everdell mirrors Catan’s resource conversion and expansion but wraps those mechanics into a strong tableau-building engine and asymmetrical card combos. While Catan’s map is modular, Everdell’s seasonal phases and hand management produce similar strategic pacing.
Gameplay highlights:
Beautiful components and layered tableau strategies
Seasonal worker placement that evolves across the game
Card combos yield exponential scoring potential
Players / Time / Weight: 1–4 players, 60–120 minutes, medium weight
Best for: Players who want theme-rich resource management with engine-building and a collectible card tableau.
Moving Beyond Catan: How to choose the right alternative
If Catan introduced you to modern tabletop mechanics, choosing the right follow-up depends on what you loved most about Catan:
Loved the trading and social negotiation? Look at games with explicit trading or negotiation mechanics (e.g., online communities often recommend negotiation-heavy euros or negotiating card games). Lords of Waterdeep’s intrigue and quest trading can scratch a similar social itch with more structure.
Loved resource management and engine building? Concordia and Splendor are natural upgrades: Concordia deepens economic planning, while Splendor condenses the loop into a fast, elegant engine.
Loved family-friendly, dice-driven fun? Stone Age keeps the resource feel while being accessible to younger or mixed-ability groups.
Wanted more theme and tableau depth? Everdell adds narrative and card synergy while preserving resource conversion decisions.
When choosing, consider player count, average playtime, and weight (how complex the game is). It’s also beneficial to have a look at the list of best games ever made in the tabletop scene to have the overview on the titles that don’t disappoint the public.
Want more recommendations for top tabletop games? Subscribe now to the newsletter and stay informed, get discounts, and more!
